Can My Employer Make Me Pay For A Mistake At Work?

Mistakes happen at work. A wrong order is placed, a customer is overcharged, stock is damaged, or equipment is broken. But what happens next is where things can get legally tricky. A question we often hear is ‘Can my employer make me pay for my mistake?’  The short answer in New Zealand is usually no, and definitely not unless very specific legal requirements are met.

In New Zealand, your wages are strongly protected by law. The key piece of legislation here is the Wages Protection Act 1983.

This Act says that your employer cannot make deductions from your wages unless you agree in writing, or the deduction is required or allowed by law, such as PAYE tax.  Even if you have agreed to deductions, there is an important safeguard that you can withdraw your consent at any time, with reasonable notice.  This means employers don’t have free rein to simply take money from your pay because something went wrong.

New Zealand case law generally supports employees in these issues. For example, the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) has repeatedly found that employers cannot rely on broad or unclear deduction clauses and employees must give genuine, informed consent before deductions can occur. In several cases, deductions for cash shortages or equipment damage have been ruled unlawful, and employers have been required to repay the money. Also, in situations where employees were asked to sign repayment agreements after a mistake, or were told they had no choice, the ERA has found that consent was not genuine and the deductions were unlawful.  So it is worthwhile getting advice if you are being asked, or forced, to pay for mistakes as your employer may be in the wrong.

When Can My Employer Make Me Pay?

There are situations where an employer may try to recover costs, but the law sets a very high bar for this.  

You Must Have Given Informed Written Consent

Employers often include clauses in employment agreements or workplace policies stating that employees may be liable for certain losses.  For example cash shortages, lost equipment or damage to company property.  However, for any deduction to be lawful you must have clearly agreed in writing, and the agreement must be specific enough to cover the situation. A vague clause like 'you are responsible for any losses' may not hold up if challenged.

The Deduction Must Be Reasonable

Even where there is written consent, deductions must still be reasonable and fair. For example was the mistake an accident? Had you been properly trained? Was the system or process flawed? And did workload or pressure contribute? If the employer contributed to the mistake, such as through poor systems or lack of training, it may be unreasonable to expect you to pay.

You Cannot Be Forced Into Agreeing

Employers cannot pressure you into signing a deduction agreement after the fact, or  make continued employment conditional on agreeing to repay a mistake.  If you feel pressured, that agreement may not be legally valid.

What About  Negligence or Serious Misconduct?

A common misconception is that if an employee is at fault,  they automatically have to pay. That’s not how it works.  Even if you were careless, or you made a serious mistake, your employer still cannot deduct wages without proper agreement.  Instead, employers usually deal with mistakes through performance management, training and/or disciplinary processes.  In extreme situations involving serious misconduct, an employer might dismiss the employee, or pursue a claim through the courts.  But direct wage deductions are still tightly controlled.

Does It Matter What Type Of Job I Have?

Some industries try to address this issue through contracts or policies.

Retail and Hospitality

It’s common to see clauses about cash register shortages or walkouts (customers leaving without paying), however blanket policies making staff automatically liable are often unlawful.   Each situation must still meet the legal requirements under the Wages Protection Act. 

Transport and Logistics

Drivers may be asked to take responsibility for vehicle damage or lost goods but, again, liability depends on the terms of the agreement and fairness of the situation.  Employers must consider factors like training, fatigue, and system failures. 

Construction and Trades

Damage to tools or materials can be expensive. Some contracts attempt to pass these costs onto workers.  However if the damage results from normal human error or unclear instructions, deductions may not be enforceable.  Health and safety obligations also play a role and employers must provide safe systems of work. 

What Should I Do If My Employer Asks Me to Pay?

If your employer says you need to repay a mistake, don’t panic, and don’t rush to agree.

Ask for the Legal Basis And Review What You Have Actually Agreed To.

Politely ask ‘Can you explain what agreement allows this deduction?' Check your employment agreement and any workplace policies you’ve signed.  Look for specific wording about deductions and whether the clause clearly covers the situation you are facing.  If it’s vague or general, it may not be enforceable.

Consider Whether It’s Fair

Ask yourself were you properly trained, was the mistake avoidable and did workplace systems contribute to the error?  Fairness matters.

Don’t Sign Under Pressure And Seek Advice

If you are asked to sign a repayment agreement take time to think and get advice before agreeing.  You are entitled to do this and your employer should not push you to sign without getting advice. You might want to consider getting help from a union (if you’re a member), a community law centre or an employment advocate.  

Raise a Personal Grievance (If Needed)

If money has already been deducted unlawfully, you may be able to raise a personal grievance for unjustified disadvantage.  Act quickly as there are strict time limits (usually 90 days).

FAQs

Can my employer deduct money from my pay without asking me?

No. They must have your written consent or legal authority.

What if I already signed a clause allowing deductions?

Even then the clause must be clear and specific, the deduction must be reasonable, and you can withdraw your consent at anytime with reasonable notice.

Can they make me pay for a customer leaving without paying?

Not automatically. This is common in hospitality, but the deduction must meet legal requirements and blanket “you must pay for walkouts” rules are often unlawful. 

What if I broke something expensive?

It depends on a number of things.  Was it accidental? Were you properly trained? Did you agree to cover such costs? Even then, deductions are not automatic.

Can I be fired instead?

Possibly, but only if the employer follows a fair disciplinary process and the mistake amounts to serious misconduct.  Most genuine mistakes do not justify dismissal.

Can my employer take the money from my final pay?

Only if there is a valid agreement, and the deduction is lawful.  

New Zealand law recognises that employees are human, and humans make mistakes.  Employers cannot simply pass the cost of doing business onto staff whenever something goes wrong. The law strikes a balance protecting employees from unfair deductions, while allowing reasonable agreements in limited circumstances.  

If your employer tries to make you pay for a mistake, the key things to remember are you have rights, you have choices and you don’t have to agree on the spot.  When in doubt, pause, seek advice, and make an informed decision.  If you are being pressured to pay for a mistake at work, or your employer has already taken a deduction, get in touch for a free consultation.  MathewsWalker.co.nz | 0800 612 355

Online Form

Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice. While we strive to keep the information accurate and up to date, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the blog or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained on the blog for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. For specific legal advice tailored to your situation, please contact a qualified legal professional.